Four-Family Home for Sale in Staten Island NY

172-174 Llewellyn Place sits in Westerleigh within Staten Island’s 10310 zip code. This 1934 four-family home for sale in Staten Island NY asks $999,000. Furthermore, it spans 3,264 square feet across four separate apartments with tenant-paid utilities and four empty garages.

172-174 Llewellyn Place four-family home for sale in Staten Island NY exterior

Four-Family Home for Sale in Staten Island NY at a Glance

Asking Price$999,000
Zillow ZestimateNot available on listing
Price per Sq. Ft.$306 / sq. ft.
Year Built1934
Size / Lot3,264 sq. ft. | Lot size not specified on listing
Bedrooms / Bathrooms4 bedrooms / 4 bathrooms total (1 bed, 1 bath per unit)
Key FeaturesFully occupied, non-regulated rents, tenant-paid utilities, 4 empty garages, sold as-is
Location172-174 Llewellyn Pl, Staten Island, NY 10310 (Westerleigh)
172-174 Llewellyn Place Staten Island NY residential unit living area

Four-Unit Layout and Tenant-Paid Utilities

This four-family home for sale in Staten Island NY divides 3,264 square feet into four separate apartments. Specifically, the building holds four bedrooms and four full bathrooms in total. Currently, tenants occupy all four units under unregulated leases. As a result, owner costs stay low because each tenant pays for heat, hot water, cooking gas, and electricity.

172-174 Llewellyn Place Staten Island NY apartment kitchen and dining area

Four Empty Garages and Sale Terms

In addition to the four rented apartments, the property features four empty garages. Owners can rent these spaces separately for extra monthly income. Meanwhile, the seller offers the building with current tenants in place and strictly as-is. Finally, the listing notes a preference for all-cash buyers or 1031 exchange deals.

172-174 Llewellyn Place Staten Island NY bedroom and interior layout

Price Analysis for 172-174 Llewellyn Place

At an asking price of $999,000, this 3,264-square-foot building equals $306 per square foot. Similarly, that price breaks down to $249,750 per apartment before counting the four garages. However, Zillow does not show a Zestimate for comparison. Monthly HOA fees are $0, while the listing estimates a monthly payment of $6,401.

172-174 Llewellyn Place Staten Island NY four garage bays and driveway access

What to Check in a 1934 Four-Family Building

  • Rent Roll and Leases: First, review signed leases, rent rolls, payment records, and security deposits for all four apartments. This confirms their unregulated rent status.
  • Four-Family Legal Status: Next, check the legal four-unit Certificate of Occupancy. Also confirm active NYC Housing Preservation and Development (HPD) registration.
  • Separate Heating and Utilities: Moreover, inspect all four boilers, water heaters, and utility meters. Since the seller offers this 1934 building as-is, check each system’s age closely.
  • Garage Condition and Rules: Finally, inspect the roof, doors, and wiring inside the four empty garages. Also check local zoning rules before renting bays to outside drivers.

Listing Credit

For full details, price history, and agent contact info, view the original listing on Zillow.

More homes in Staten Island: