Built in 2023 on a 40.08 x 100-foot parcel in Staten Island’s 10314 zip code, 96 Coale Avenue is a legal two-family duplex listed at $1,449,000. This 2,385-square-foot new-construction residence pairs two self-contained multi-bath apartments with a finished basement, private balconies, and a two-car driveway, making this two-family home in Staten Island NY well suited for owner-occupants seeking rental income.
Two-Family Duplex at a Glance
| Asking Price | $1,449,000 |
| Zillow Zestimate | Not available on listing |
| Price per Sq. Ft. | $608 / sq. ft. |
| Year Built | 2023 |
| Size / Lot | 2,385 sq. ft. (43 x 25 ft building) | 40.08 x 100 ft lot (Zoning: R3X) |
| Bedrooms / Bathrooms | 4 listed bedrooms (+ attic bedroom) / 5 baths across units (6 listed) |
| Key Features | Finished basement, attic with bathroom rough-in, dual balconies, zoned central HVAC, 2-car driveway |
| Location | 96 Coale Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314 |
Two Independent Multi-Level Residences
Both apartments span generous footprints finished with new hardwood flooring, large windows, and built-in networking wired for 20 internet ports per unit. On the ground level, an open living area flows into an island kitchen equipped with new appliances, a dishwasher, and dedicated laundry machines, accompanied by two bedrooms, 2.5 baths—including a primary suite with a soaking jacuzzi—and interior access to a fully finished basement. Upstairs, the second apartment mirrors the open island-kitchen layout with two bedrooms, 2.5 baths, separate laundry, and a bonus attic level offering an additional sleeping room with plumbing already roughed in for a future bath.
Outdoor Space, Parking, and Building Systems
Set on a 40.08 x 100-foot lot under R3X zoning (built at a 0.60 FAR against a 0.75 maximum), the property balances indoor volume with private outdoor retreats. Each residence enjoys its own private balcony overlooking a landscaped garden and rear terrace, while a private driveway accommodates two vehicles off the street. Mechanical upgrades include zoned central heating and air conditioning along with an integrated security monitoring system.
Price Analysis
At an asking price of $1,449,000, the property is priced at $608 per square foot across its 2,385 square feet of above-grade living space, with no Zillow Zestimate currently published for comparison. Annual property taxes are listed at $10,221 (roughly $852 per month) with $0 HOA fees, and the listing estimates a total monthly payment of $9,372.
What to Check in a 2023 Two-Family Duplex
- Certificate of Occupancy & Attic Plumbing: Verify that the two-family legal status, finished basement, and existing attic plumbing rough-ins align with NYC Department of Buildings approvals before adding a fixture.
- Separate Utility Metering: Confirm whether gas, electric, and the zoned central HVAC systems are metered independently so each apartment can be billed separately.
- Builder Warranties & Waterproofing: Inspect foundation drainage, basement moisture barriers, and remaining manufacturer warranties on the 2023 mechanicals, roof, and appliances.
- Actual vs. Virtually Staged Rooms: Because several listing photos include virtual furniture, measure room dimensions in person against the 43 x 25-foot building footprint.
Listing Credit
For full details, price history and to contact the listing agent, see the original listing on Zillow.
More homes in Staten Island: