Two-Family Home for Sale in Staten Island NY: 278 Caswell Ave ($849.9K)

278 Caswell Avenue occupies an oversized corner parcel in Westerleigh within Staten Island’s 10314 zip code. Built in 1925, this legal two-family home for sale in Staten Island NY currently functions as a single-family residence and lists at $849,888. Furthermore, it spans 1,595 square feet with four bedrooms, two bathrooms, a sun-filled window foyer, abundant attic storage, and a detached garage.

278 Caswell Avenue legal two-family home for sale in Staten Island NY corner exterior

Two-Family Home for Sale in Staten Island NY at a Glance

Before examining the interior layout, corner lot advantages, and legal two-family zoning flexibility, the summary table below highlights every verified specification from the listing. Specifically, buyers can review the asking price, square footage, and key structural features at a glance.

Asking Price$849,888
Zillow Zestimate$847,000
Price per Sq. Ft.$533 / sq. ft.
Year Built1925
Size / Lot1,595 sq. ft. | Oversized corner lot (exact dimensions not listed)
Bedrooms / Bathrooms4 bedrooms / 2 bathrooms total
Key FeaturesLegal 2-family used as 1-family, window-lined foyer, spacious eat-in kitchen with laundry area, separate living and dining rooms, abundant attic storage, detached garage
Location278 Caswell Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314 (Westerleigh)
278 Caswell Avenue Staten Island NY window-lined foyer and main living room

Main-Level Flow, Window Foyer, and Eat-In Kitchen

This two-family home for sale in Staten Island NY organizes 1,595 square feet of living space across a classic 1925 floor plan. Upon entry, a welcoming foyer lined with windows brings natural light straight into the front of the home. From there, distinct living and dining rooms create clear separation between casual relaxation and formal gatherings.

Toward the rear of the main level, a spacious eat-in kitchen accommodates daily family meals without requiring use of the formal dining room. Directly integrated into the kitchen zone, a convenient laundry area keeps everyday household chores on the main floor rather than tucked away in a dark corner. Across the residence, four bedrooms and two bathrooms provide comfortable accommodation for larger households.

278 Caswell Avenue Staten Island NY spacious eat-in kitchen with laundry area

Legal Two-Family Status Used as a Single-Family Residence

One of the defining advantages of 278 Caswell Avenue lies in its legal two-family classification paired with its current single-family setup. Because the property already holds legal two-family status, buyers gain valuable long-term flexibility in Westerleigh’s 10314 market. Specifically, new owners can continue enjoying the entire 1,595-square-foot home as a unified single-family residence with four bedrooms and two bathrooms.

Alternatively, future owners who want rental income or dedicated quarters for extended relatives have a legal two-family framework to work from, subject to layout verification and local building rules. Meanwhile, abundant attic storage overhead gives the household ample room for seasonal items, luggage, and keepsakes without encroaching on primary living areas.

278 Caswell Avenue Staten Island NY bedroom and upper-level living space

Oversized Corner Lot and Detached Garage

Outside, the residence sits on an oversized corner lot in the Westerleigh section of Staten Island. Corner positioning delivers wider street frontage, greater separation from neighboring structures, and multi-sided daylight throughout the day. In addition, corner parcels often provide easier curb access and more flexible yard zones for gardening, outdoor seating, or play areas.

Completing the exterior package, a detached garage offers secure covered parking as well as supplemental storage for tools, bicycles, and outdoor equipment. Having an enclosed garage on a corner parcel keeps vehicles protected from winter snow and summer heat while freeing up street parking along Caswell Avenue.

278 Caswell Avenue Staten Island NY oversized corner lot and detached garage

Price Analysis and Monthly Payment Breakdown for 278 Caswell Avenue

At an asking price of $849,888, this 1925 Westerleigh property sits virtually dead even with automated valuation benchmarks. Specifically, the list price is just $2,888—or 0.34%—above its $847,000 Zillow Zestimate. Calculated across its 1,595 square feet of living space, the asking figure equals $533 per square foot.

Furthermore, monthly HOA dues are $0, avoiding ongoing association fees. According to the listing’s financing calculator, the estimated monthly payment comes out to $5,445. Compared with neighboring Westerleigh listings—such as the single-family residence at 473 Collfield Ave #A ($798,000 at $542/sq. ft.) and the two-family duplex at 66 Lyon Pl ($1,100,000 at $466/sq. ft.)—278 Caswell Avenue sits squarely in the mid-tier pricing bracket while offering legal two-family flexibility.

What to Check in a 1925 Legal Two-Family Home

Purchasing a century-old legal two-family house that currently operates as a one-family residence calls for targeted legal and structural due diligence. Before finalizing an offer on 278 Caswell Avenue, buyers and home inspectors should review four key areas:

  • Certificate of Occupancy and Two-Family Configuration: First, pull the official NYC Department of Buildings Certificate of Occupancy or I-Card records to verify legal two-family status. In addition, confirm how kitchens, entrances, and utility meters are currently configured if you plan to restore a second apartment later.
  • 1925 Framing, Foundation, and Electrical Wiring: Next, have a licensed home inspector evaluate the foundation walls, floor joists, plumbing supply lines, and electrical panel. Homes built in 1925 often feature a mix of original woodwork and later mechanical updates that warrant careful verification.
  • Attic Insulation, Ventilation, and Roof Decking: Because the property highlights abundant attic storage, inspect the underside of the roof sheathing, rafters, and insulation levels. Proper ridge or soffit ventilation prevents summer heat buildup and winter condensation around stored belongings.
  • Detached Garage Roof, Slab, and Corner Setbacks: Finally, examine the detached garage roof, overhead door mechanism, and concrete floor slab for settling or water intrusion. Also check corner-lot fence and curb-cut regulations before making exterior changes.

Who This 10314 Corner Property Fits Best

Overall, 278 Caswell Avenue fits buyers looking for classic 1925 Westerleigh character, an oversized corner lot, and legal two-family optionality. Families needing four bedrooms, separate living and dining rooms, and a detached garage can move in and enjoy the entire home as a single residence right away. At the same time, long-term planners gain the underlying legal two-family classification for future multi-generational living or rental income.

Listing Credit

For full details, price history, and agent contact info, view the original listing on Zillow.

More homes in Staten Island: